Opens in a new tab

Is that email really from us? How to spot a scam that knows your name

Scam emails now borrow the names of businesses you trust. Here's what happened to our clients, and the three checks to run before you pay for anything.
A single fishing hook hanging against a soft blue sky

Last weekend a bunch of our clients got an email from “me”. It said their website maintenance was due for renewal, and to reply “proceed” so we could send through the details to update their payment.

It wasn’t me, and that’s pretty shit.

The short answer

Before you pay anything or change any payment details, run three checks. Look at the actual email address, not just the name, and ask whether you’ve had an email from it before. Treat every payment request as a red flag until it passes your own check, even small ones. Then confirm with a second source you already trust, like the company’s app or a text to someone you know there. If anything doesn’t line up, don’t reply, don’t click, and don’t pay.

What actually happened

I wasn’t hacked, and neither were our clients. That’s the important bit.

Someone looked at our business, saw that we offer website maintenance, worked out who our clients are from what I share on Instagram, and emailed them pretending to be me.

That’s where scams are at now. Everything gets scraped and fed into AI. A friend of mine had her voice scraped and deepfaked, and the scammer has been ringing her clients asking for more money. A familiar name, or even a familiar voice, isn’t proof any more.

Three checks before you pay anything

1. Check the actual email address

Your email app shows a display name, and anyone can type any name they like. Tap or hover on it and look at the address underneath. Have you actually had an email from this address before? If not, treat it as a scam until you’ve proven otherwise.

2. Treat every payment request as a red flag

Every request to pay, renew, or “update your payment details” has to get past your own QA first. Even if it’s just your Disney+.

3. Verify with a second source

Don’t use the phone number, link or reply address in the email itself. Go to the source a different way: open the company’s app, log in to your account directly, or send a text to the person you already deal with. A couple of our clients texted me “is this you?” Nope, absolutely not.

When the email really is from someone you know

People do get hacked. So a scam can arrive from the genuine address of someone you have a real relationship with. That’s why the second-source check matters even when the first check passes.

If you’ve already clicked, replied or paid

Move quickly, and don’t be embarrassed. These scams are built to catch busy, trusting people.

  • Paid, or shared card or bank details? Call your bank straight away. They may be able to stop or recover the payment.
  • Report it to Scamwatch at scamwatch.gov.au/report-a-scam. If you’ve lost money or your accounts were broken into, you can also report it through ReportCyber.
  • Worried your identity’s been compromised? IDCARE offers free support to help you work out what to do next.
  • Tell the business that was impersonated, through a channel you already trust, so they can warn everyone else.

Have this chat with the people in your life

Explain this to the other people in your life too, especially our older folks.

What to expect from us

If you’re one of our clients, I’ve emailed you with what to expect from us when we need to update your payment details. If something ever looks off, check with us the way you normally would before you do anything. We’d much rather get an “is this you?” text than have you caught out.

And how do these people sleep at night?

Look after yourself, eat your greens, and don’t fall for phishing.

Keeping your website looked after

Care Plans won’t stop a scam email landing in your inbox. But if you’d like someone keeping an eye on your website’s security, updates and backups, that’s what our Care Plans are for.

Related reading: Why You Should Own Your Domain Name.

Quick Fire Questions!

Check the actual sender address, not just the display name, and ask whether you've had email from it before. Be wary of anything asking you to pay, renew, reply or update payment details, especially with a deadline. If in doubt, confirm with the company through a channel you already use, never through the email itself.

Yes. If someone's email account is hacked, scam emails can come from their genuine address. That's why a payment request should always be confirmed through a second source, like a text, a phone number you already have, or the company's own app, even when the sender looks right.

Contact your bank immediately, because acting fast gives you the best chance of stopping or recovering the payment. Then, in Australia, report it to Scamwatch, and through ReportCyber if money or accounts were involved. IDCARE offers free support if you're worried about your identity.

Often from public information. Websites, social media posts, reviews and tags can show who works with whom. With AI tools scraping the web, scammers can piece that together quickly, so an email can mention real businesses and real services without anyone being hacked.

Still have questions?

We love a curious cookie. If you’ve got a burning question we haven’t covered here, get in touch—we’re real humans, we don’t bite, and we’d love to help you figure out if we’re the right fit.

Contact Us Now

Not quite ready to hit “go”?

No stress. If you’re still wrapping your head around what your website needs (or if you just want to not mess it up), grab our No-Regrets Website Guide.

It walks you through the five things you need to get clear on before you start a website project—so you can stop second-guessing and start making smart moves.

An iPad displaying a website guide titled "Your No-Regrets Website Guide" next to a spiral notebook and pen on a desk.

Leave the first comment

More, you say?